Martha’s Vineyard Casino Faces Opposition

Updated On Apr 24, 2017
Paige Williams Paige Williams Casino Writer
Fact Checked Reviewer Dave Cooper Dave Cooper Casino Expert

Editorial Statement: At CasinoUS, we independently review and select the online casinos featured on our site. We assess each operator using consistent criteria covering licensing, security, payments, payouts, bonuses, games, customer support and responsible gambling.

We may earn commissions when readers use certain affiliate links. However, commercial relationships do not determine which casinos we feature or how we evaluate them. We highlight both strengths and limitations so that US players can make more informed decisions.

Earlier in April, the proposed Martha’s Vineyard casino was given the legal go-ahead. However, since it received the green light from the law, the proposed project has started to receive strong opposition from local residents on the island in Massachusetts.

Martha’s Vineyard Casino opposed by locals

Tribe Gets Blessing for Martha’s Vineyard Casino

In mid-April 2017, the local Native American tribe, the Wampanoag Tribe of Gay Head, was in a court battle for the right to build a casino. Its request had previously been denied, and the tribe appealed the court’s decision. The federal court sided with the Native American group in its appeal, and it was granted permission to build the Martha’s Vineyard casino on its reservation property on the island.

However, since the decisions, local officials and residents have opposed the news and are trying to fight the ruling. Current plans will have the Martha’s Vineyard Casino built near the town of Aquinnah, which is located on the western edge of the island.

A spokesman from the town believes the current court ruling is incorrect. He believes that the town’s laws and those of the state apply to all tribal land on the island, including the laws related to gambling.

As it stands right now, the casino will house around 300 electronic betting machines, but there will not be any table games at this time. This is because the tribe will require a compact with the state in order to offer table games.

Town Brings Up Previous Agreement

The town’s people are arguing that the Wampanoag tribe does not have the right to offer gambling services on its land, as it agreed not to offer any games of chance when it received its federal recognition 30 years ago. The tribe, on the other hand, says that commercial gambling was legalized in the state in 2011, which makes the original agreement void.

In the end, there is very little the town can do. Their only legal option would be to try and take their case to the Supreme Court. However, the Supreme Court receives over 7000 requests every year and only looks into 80 of them.

Paige Williams

Paige Williams

Paige Williams is the Editor-in-Chief at CasinoUS.com, where she leads the editorial strategy and content standards across the platform. She specializes in casino bonuses, promotions, and player reward programs, ensuring every guide is accurate, transparent, and designed to help players make informed decisions.

Editorial Statement: Casino US is your trusted source for timely industry updates, in-depth analysis, and honest operator reviews. Our editorial team brings years of specialized gaming industry knowledge to every story, holding ourselves to strict standards of accuracy and objectivity. We're dedicated to providing straightforward, unbiased, and reliable reporting on the US gambling landscape and beyond.